Caragor vs Valentino: who would win?

Too close to call

Caragor · Lord of the Rings · Caragor/Caragath

Tier
8-C
Attack Potency
Building Level
Speed
Subsonic+
Durability
Building Level

Valentino · Hazbin Hotel · Base

Tier
8-C
Attack Potency
Building Level
Speed
Subsonic+, up to Supersonic
Durability
Building Level

A heuristic estimate from normalized VS Battles Wiki stats: tier, attack potency, speed and durability.